Cincinnati should feel great about No. 7 CFP ranking, but there

When the School Soccer Playoff acknowledged halfway via November its plan for members of its choice committee to fulfill in individual every week to debate their rankings, there was fairly a ruckus within the media.

It appeared needlessly dangerous for everybody to journey within the midst of the pandemic, particularly when the weekly ordering of CFP contenders they produce is “for amusement functions solely.” It incorporates no lasting worth.

There’s additionally the inherent contradiction: The committee telephones in these rankings, anyway.

MORE: Bearcats’ CFP case is backed by these surprising stats

It seems charming to some for the Cincinnati Bearcats to be listed as excessive as No. 7 within the official CFP rankings, and it even has generated ostensibly considerate dialogue amongst those that cowl the game that this placement assures that UC is being TAKEN SERIOUSLY as a contender for one of many 4 spots within the 2020 occasion. ESPN’s “Soccer Energy Index” even provides the Bearcats a 33.four % probability of reaching the playoff. And, hey, that is science.

The truth is, itemizing the Bearcats as No. 7 is all of the reminder anybody wants that they’ve bought zero.zero probability to be chosen.

Sure, that is a full Blutarsky.

The location of Texas A&M at No. 5 and Florida at No. 6 is exactly the proof obligatory to identify the charade. The CFP committee will rustle via all of the closets on the Southeastern Convention looking for some staff with a consultant report to put in in entrance of an off-brand staff corresponding to Cincinnati. No mixture of outcomes over the ultimate weeks of the season will alter this method, whether or not the votes are forged in individual, by a Zoom name or — gasp! — via the U.S. mail.

If the committee certainly have been taking the Bearcats significantly, its members would have positioned them within the No. 5 place they earned with their excellent report so far. They might have wanted assist from there to make it into the sphere, however additionally they would have wanted to avoiding screwing it up.

It has been a mistake from the start to simply accept the CFP as a professional championship occasion. Its solely benefit is that it occurs to be extra constructive than what it changed, the Bowl Championship Collection, which was extra constructive than the Bowl Alliance, which was extra constructive than merely a bunch of individuals voting to resolve the champion.

The CFP should be recognized strictly by its acronym. Overlook what the letters symbolize, as a result of they’re a misnomer. This isn’t really a playoff. It’s an invitational. A competitor doesn’t qualify for entry into the CFP the best way a tennis participant does to enter the U.S. Open or a soccer staff does to enter the MLS Cup playoffs.

The champion of the Pac-12 Convention has been ignored by the committee 4 occasions in six years. The champion of the Huge Ten has made it 3 times in six years. These are two of the NCAA autonomy conferences that the media have chosen to designate because the “Energy 5,” and but no matter energy is contained inside generally is ignored by CFP selectors.

The CFP operates nearer to the ethic of a junior excessive celebration than an occasion such because the NCAA Match, which incorporates the 32 who qualify to compete for the championship and people 36 deemed worthy of filling out the sphere by a variety committee. The CFP desires the cool children. The cool children make for a greater TV present, or not less than one prone to produce increased TV rankings.

MORE: Week 14 picks against the spread for every top 25 game

Cincinnati fairly clearly will not be one of many cool children. When faculty athletics was convulsed by the convention enlargement revolution almost a decade in the past, nobody wished the Bearcats. By no means thoughts that they’d six Remaining Fours and two NCAA championships in males’s basketball or that their out of the blue energized soccer program had gained three Huge East championships in 5 years and lately had produced such NFL luminaries as Connor Barwin, Derek Wolfe and Travis Kelce. Or that they have been in a gorgeous location and media market.

The Bearcats have been left behind within the Huge East, which quickly dissolved into the “new” Huge East for the basketball-first personal faculties and the AAC for everybody else. No staff from the American — not even UCF’s extraordinary, unbeaten 2017 staff — has been invited to the CFP.

And none will.

That’s not me saying none ought to.

That’s me saying I’ve seen this movie earlier than, and I didn’t just like the ending.